Black Hole Simulations Take Us inside the Mind of Einstein

10 May 2006

A visualization of a three-dimensional
computer simulation which shows gravitational radiation emitted by two
merging black holes. Researchers crunched equations from Einstein's
theory of general relativity on the Columbia supercomputer at the
NASA Ames Research Center to create this three-dimensional simulation.
(7.4 Mb - no audio).(Credit: Henze, NASA)

For years scientists trying to visualize the concept of gravitational waves churned by the collision of black holes have relied largely on artists' conceptions. Now, at long last, they have Einstein's conception.

According to Einstein's math, when two massive black holes merge, all of space jiggles like a bowl of Jell-O as gravitational waves race out from the collision at light speed.

NASA scientists have reached a breakthrough in computer modeling
that allows them to simulate what gravitational waves from merging
black holes look like. The three-dimensional simulations are a
manifestation of Einstein's equations. As the largest astrophysical
calculations ever performed on a NASA supercomputer, they also provide the foundation to explore the universe in an entirely new way.

Previous simulations had been plagued by computer crashes. The necessary equations, based on Einstein's theory of general relativity, were far too complex. But scientists at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Md., have found a method to translate Einstein's math in a way that computers can understand.
"These mergers are by far the most powerful events occurring in the universe, with each one generating more energy than all of the stars in the universe combined. Now we have realistic simulations to guide gravitational wave detectors coming online," said Joan Centrella, head of the Gravitational Astrophysics Laboratory at Goddard.

The Columbia Supercomputer at NASA's Advanced Supercomputing Facility
at Ames Research Center. It consists of a 10,240-processor SGI
Altix system comprised of 20 nodes, each with 512 Intel Itanium 2
processors, and running a Linux operating system. (Click on image to view large resolution.) Credit: Trower, NASA

The simulations were performed on the Columbia supercomputer at NASA's Ames Research Center near Mountain View, Calif. This work appears in the March 26 issue of Physical Review Letters and will appear in an upcoming issue of Physical Review D. The lead author is John Baker of Goddard.

Similar to ripples on a pond, gravitational waves are ripples in space and time, a four-dimensional concept that Einstein called spacetime. They haven't yet been directly detected.

Gravitational waves hardly interact with matter and thus can
penetrate the dust and gas that blocks our view of black holes and
other objects. They offer a new window to explore the universe and
provide a precise test for Einstein's theory of general
relativity. The National Science Foundation's ground-based Laser
Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) and the proposed
Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA), a joint NASA - European Space Agency project, hope to detect these subtle waves, which would alter the shape of a human from head to toe by far less than the width of an atom.

Black hole mergers produce copious gravitational waves, sometimes for years, as the black holes approach each other and collide. Black holes are regions where gravity is so extreme that nothing, not even light, can escape their pull. They alter spacetime. Therein lies the difficulty in creating black hole models: space and time shift, density becomes infinite and time can come to a standstill. Such variables cause computer simulations to crash.

These massive, colliding objects produce gravitational waves of differing wavelengths and strengths, depending on the masses involved. The Goddard team has perfected the simulation of merging, equal-mass, non-spinning black holes starting at various positions corresponding to the last two to five orbits before their merger.

With each simulation run, regardless of the starting point, the black holes orbited stably and produced identical waveforms during the collision and its aftermath. This unprecedented combination of stability and reproducibility assured the scientists that the simulations were true to Einstein's equations. The team has since moved on to simulating mergers of non-equal-mass black holes.

Einstein's theory of general relativity employs a type of
mathematics called tensor calculus, which cannot be turned into
computer instructions easily, Baker explained. The equations need to be translated, which greatly expands them. The simplest tensor calculus equations require thousands of lines of computer code. The expansions, called formulations, can be written in many ways. Through mathematical intuition, the Goddard team found the appropriate formulations that led to suitable simulations.

Progress also has been made independently by several groups, including researchers at the Center for Gravitational Wave Astronomy at the University of Texas, Brownsville, which is supported by the NASA Minority University Research and Education Program.

"These simulations enable us to visualize Einstein's equations," said
Dr. Paul Hertz, Chief Scientist, NASA's Science Mission
Directorate. "Now when we observe a black hole merger with LIGO or
LISA, we can test Einstein's theory and see whether or not he was
right."

As of November 2005, LIGO is up and running and could, in theory, detect gravitational waves from stellar-size black hole mergers any day. LISA, in the planning stages, could detect longer-wavelength gravitational radiation from supermassive black holes. The beauty of the NASA simulations is that they can be scaled to fit either scenario.

Additional Links

Visit the Beyond Einstein site. (http://beyondeinstein.gsfc.nasa.gov/)

Imagine the Universe is a service of the High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Research Center (HEASARC), Dr. Alan Smale (Director), within the Astrophysics Science Division (ASD) at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center.