(Submitted October 27, 1998)
Recently, in physics class we learned that the orbit of
Pluto was not co-planar to the other eight planets, in fact
it was 17 degrees off! I want to know why this is? If you
would be so kind as to answer my question and e-mail me back
I would be much obliged.
The other important thing about Pluto's orbit is the 3:2 resonance
between Pluto and Neptune; that is, in the time it takes Pluto to orbit
around the Sun twice, Neptune will have orbited the Sun three times.
It is clear from this that there is a special relationship between
the orbits of Neptune and Pluto, and also probably the origins of
Neptune and Pluto.
Starting in 1992, astronomers (such as Dr. David Jewitt at University
of Hawaii) have began to discover a large number of small objects in
the outer Solar System, the so-called Kuiper Belt. It turns out that
a surprising number of these are also in 3:2 resonance with Neptune.
These are nicknamed "Plutinos", or little Plutos:
Many Plutinos share properties of the high eccentricities and
significant inclinations with Pluto. It is therefore natural to
associate the presence of so many Plutinos with their interesting
According to one theory (which Dr. Jewitt calls 'as good as any,
and better than most'), Neptune migrated outwards during the accretion
stage of solar system formation. During this process, Neptune trapped
many planetesimals in the 3:2 resonance and carried them outwards with
it. Although these planetesimals were originally
in more or less circular orbits on the same plane as the planets,
their eccentricities and inclinations increased as they were pushed
Clearly, this is not a settled question, and more theoretical and
observational works are necessary.
Here are a selection of other web sites related to this question:
Koji Mukai & Maggie Masetti
for Ask an Astrophysicist
Questions on this topic are no longer responded to by the "Ask an Astrophysicist" service. See http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/ask_an_astronomer.html
for help on other astronomy Q&A services.